Overall Ranking
Overview Criteria Overall Ranking Links BBQ Index

 

Home
1999 Results
2000 Results
2001 Results
2002 Results
2003 Results
2004 Results

Welcome to the Results Summary page.  A single page ranking really can't do justice to hundreds of barbecue joints, so please visit the links to the left to get a better flavor for each of the distinct barbecue styles encountered during our tours.  That is also where you will find the detailed reviews of each joint, including comments and pictures.

Overall Rankings

ID Rank Name Tour_ID City Year Rank Note Rating  Awards
1 Little Richard's   Winston-Salem, NC 2008     4.44 Meat Category Winner; Best Sliced; Atmosphere
15 2 Louie Mueller Barbecue 2 Taylor 1999, 2000
and 2007
2   4.42 1999:Sausage (regular & jalapeño), Beef Shoulder
2000:Sausage (regular & jalapeño), Atmosphere
2007: Atmosphere
11 3 Kreuz Market Inc 2 Lockhart 1999, 2000
and 2007
1   4.38 1999:Prime Rib, Pork Chop, Beef Shoulder
2000:Overall Winner; Lean Brisket, Pork Chop, Prime Rib
2007: Beef Shoulder
4 Allen & Son   Chapel Hill, NC 2008     4.33 Best Sliced; Brunswick Stew; Sides; Hush Puppies
22 5 City Market 2 Luling 1999, 2000
and 2007
2   4.23 1999:Ribs, Runner-up Sausage
2000:Ribs
2007: Overall Winner; Meat, Sides, Sauce
6 Lexington Barbecue   Lexington, NC 2008     4.12 Best Peach Cobbler
42 7 Smitty's 2 Lockhart 2000 and 2007 5   4.08 2000: Fatty Brisket, Atmosphere
2007: Pork Chop
16 8 Zimmerhanzel's   Smithville 2007     4.06 Ribs, Sausage
9 Ronnie Ingle   Abilene 2006     4.04 Brisket, Atmosphere, Sauce
10 Barbecue Center   Lexington, NC 2008     4.00 Best Sauce ("Dip"); Tallest banana split
37 10 Carter's Bar-B-Que 3 Longview 2001 2   4.00 Spare Rib, Sausage, Atmosphere
12 Angelo's 3 Fort Worth 2001 and 2004 1   3.97 2001: Overall Winner, Brisket, Atmosphere
2004: Atmosphere
6 13 Hammond's B-B-Q 3 Glen Rose 2001 and 2004 4   3.89 2001: Atmosphere, Dessert
2004: Dessert
27 14 Goss Store 8 Belmont 2003 1   3.88 Sauce co-winner w/BBQ Patio
15 Stamey's   Greensboro, NC 2008     3.85 Best Dessert; Cherry Cobbler
38 16 Floyd's Barbeque   Fort Worth 2004 2   3.83 Meat Category Winner, Sausage
66 17 Pit Stop   Breckenridge 2006     3.76 Sausage and  Meat Category Winner
18 Austin's Bar-B-Que 4 Eagle Lake 2002 1 Old converted gas station.  Friendly folks; good 'Q; and homeade desserts.  Plus they are trying to get their sausage into grocery stores, and were working on the recipe… We'd definitely recommend picking some up if you see it in your grocer's refrigerated case! 3.74 Overall Winner, Sausage
12 19 Mustang Creek BBQ 4 Louise 2002 2 Now this is a joint!  No signs, no indoor plumbing, no A/C.  But mighty fine 'Q. 3.72 Pork Ribs, Pulled Pork
40 20 Hinze's Bar-B-Que 4 Wharton 2002 3 A BBQ institution in this area… and deservedly so.  Pecan smoked meats with large pecan trees growing INSIDE the establishement.  They have their own exit off of Northbound 59. 3.72 Atmosphere, Brisket, Sauce
21 Hillsdale Bank   Paola, KS    2005     3.69 Atmosphere, Sauce
59 22 BB's Lawnside   KC, MO 2005     3.67 Runner-up Atmosphere, Runner-up Overall
52 23 Rosedale   KC, KS 2005     3.65 Runner-up Meat Category
51 24 Railhead Smokehouse 3 Fort Worth 2001 and 2004 3   3.65 2001: Spare Rib, Brisket
2004: Sauce
41 25 Big Earl's 8 Kerrville 2003 2   3.64 Meat Category Winner
26 Old Time Pit Bar-B-Q   San Angelo 2006     3.62 Runner-up Brisket; Runner-up Ribs
27 Hard Eight Pit Bar-B-Q   Stephenville 2004 and 2006     3.62 2004: Runner-up Atmosphere
2006: Sides
28 Williams Smoke House 4 Houston 2002 4 Opens at 11:00am.  Good ole Willie B. started this place 15 years ago, and is still growing it today. 3.60  
29 Jack Stack   KC, MO 2005     3.60 Meat Category Winner
74 30 Sam's Bar-B-Cue 2 Austin 1999 and 2000 7   3.60 1999: Mutton
2000: Mutton, Late Night BBQ
30 Burnet County Bar-B-Que 2 Burnet 2000 8   3.60 Best Party Ham
43 30 Cartwright's Bar-B-Q 2 Bastrop 2000 8   3.60  
30 Crosstown Bar-B-Q 2 Elgin 2000 8   3.60 Nicest Folks
13 30 Inmans Ranch House Bar-B-Q 2 Marble Falls 2000 8   3.60 Best Turkey Sausage 
18 35 Scott's Barbecue 4 West Columbia 2002 5 Hardtack Café burned in 2000, but Scott (encouraged by local patrons) is still servin' up the 'Q.  We were treated with Live Oak smoked meats & his tremendous hospitality.  Thanks for the terrific tour, Scott! 3.58  
36 Deano's   Mocksville, NC 2008     3.58 Best Banana Pudding
37 Grady's   Dudley, NC 2008     3.55  
19 38 Black's Barbecue 1 Lockhart 1999 and 2007 3   3.52 1999: Best Pork Loin 
17 39 Big Boys   Sweetwater 2006     3.51 "My Way" Country Style Ribs; Jalapeno Popper
68 40 Kozy Kitchen 4 Houston 2002 6 Supposed to open at 11:00am - we had to come back later because they weren't yet open.  But the second trip was worth the effort! 3.50 Sides, Sliced Pork, Veal
50 41 Harry's on the Loop 2 Willow City 2000 and 2007 2   3.50 2000: Best Attitude (Laid Back, Hill Country)
2007: Guac-a-dillo
41 Country Tavern 3 Kilgore 2001 5   3.50 Runner-up Rib
55 41 Jerry's BBQ 3 Aledo 2001 6   3.50 Hot Link
2 41 Riverport Bbq 3 Jefferson 2001 7   3.50 Pork Loin
1 41 Salt Lick - Bergstrom 1 Austin 1999 5   3.50 Best airport BBQ stand
39 46 Brian's BBQ 4 Clute 2002 7 Opens at 11:00am.  This place was starting to get very busy by 11:15… a good sign!  This was a solid joint for our first stop of the day. 3.50  
48 Wilber's   Goldsboro, NC 2008     3.49  
26 47 Lil' Jakes Eat it and Beat it   KC, MO 2005     3.49  
49 49 Taylor Café 2 Taylor 2000 and 2007 6   3.48 Best Late Addition to the BBQ Tour
50 Bun 'N' Barrel 8 San Antonio 2003 4   3.46 Sausage co-winner w/Gonzales Mkt
62 51 Ranch House Barbecue   Glen Rose 2004 5   3.45 Rib
52 Gonzales Food Market 8 Gonzales 2003 and 2007 3   3.43 2003: Brisket; Sausage co-winner w/Bun-N-Barrel
2007: Cole Slaw
53 Coopers Barbeque   Mason 2007     3.41 Cabrito
20 54 Big Smith's Bar-B-Q 3 Sulpher Springs 2001 9 We never would've stumbled onto this place if it weren't for the help of a rodeo clown… Ask K-Dog to tell you the whole story! 3.40 Beef Rib, Pork Loin, Attitude
21 54 North Main Bar Bq 3 Eueless 2001 8   3.40  
33 54 Brothers Bar Bq 2 Llano 2000 12   3.40 Cabrito, Corn Nuggets
35 54 Coopers Barbeque 2 Llano 2000 12   3.40 Pork Chop, Sirloin, Atmosphere
75 58 Buzzie's BBQ 8 Comfort 2003 5   3.34 Sides
59 Cotton Belt BBQ   North Richland Hills 2004 7   3.33  
60 Artz Rib House   Austin 2007     3.32 Country Style Rib, Baby Back Rib, Beef Rib
61 Woodyard   KC, KS 2005     3.32  
28 62 Leon's BarBQ 3 Shreveport 2001 11 It's a good thing the Barrow brother's spent so much time in the casino… otherwise we wouldn't have referrals to Leon's from the staff and local patrons.  Thanks! 3.30 Hot Link
23 62 Outlaw's Bar-B-Que 3 Daingerfield 2001 10   3.30  
31 62 Sonny Bryan's Smokehouse 3 Dallas 2001 12   3.30  
65 Bar-B-Q Barn   Buffalo Gap 2006     3.29  
54 66 Drexler's Bar-B-Que 4 Houston 2002 8 We started Day3 here, because Kozy Kitchen was having some trouble opening on time today.  On the fringes of downtown; I'm sure that they have a mean business lunch rush. 3.29 Hot Link
67 Laird's   Llano 2007     3.26  
53 68 The Swinging Door 4 Richmond 2002 9 An established barbecue restaurant with a dance floor.  Hosts many organized functions/groups for dinner and dancing. 3.25  
69 Harold's   Abilene 2006     3.23  
70 Joe Allen's   Abilene 2006     3.22  
71 Pit Downtown Barbecue 2 Austin 2000 14   3.20 Oldest Building on Tour
14 72 Salt Lick   Driftwood 2007     3.19  
73 Texas   Stephenville 2006     3.18  
74 Square's   Abilene 2006     3.17  
46 75 Joe's Barbeque Co 4 Alvin 2002 10 An Alvin institution… this place reminds us of Southside in Elgin.  It's a huge place in a small town.  A barbecue restaurant - but the sign out front is advertising their fajita special. 3.15  
47 76 Grand Prize BBQ 4 Texas City 2002 11 An old converted seafood house? Gas-fired pits around back. 3.14  
69 77 Bolners Meat Market 8 San Antonio 2003 6   3.14 Hot Link and Dessert co-winner w/BBQ Patio
70 78 R Bbq 8 Sabinal 2003 7   3.12 Spare Rib
79 LC's   KC, MO 2005     3.11  
80 Riscky's   Fort Worth 2004 8   3.10 Brisket
81 Short Sugar's   Reidsville, NC 2008     3.09